Showing posts with label EU. Show all posts
Showing posts with label EU. Show all posts

Tuesday, 28 June 2016

In support of the leavers

I know I need to stop blogging about all this politics stuff. You all want to hear funny stories about children who say amusing things in flute lessons but I can't do it. They're not even making me smile much at the moment. I expect some of you, knowing that I am in full on end of year mode thought I would be writing about the wonderful year six children, who will soon go on to bigger and better things. Sorry. Sometimes I  just need to get things off my chest. (Why do we say that? It's not on my chest. It's in my head)

I did a stupid thing this morning. I was awake early and I stepped out of my bubble and looked at the tweets of Katie Hopkins. I love my bubble. It's full of nice people, who are kind to others and care about each other.

There was a reason. I'm trying to understand. There has been too much division and people are cross and scared.  Leave voters are particularly scared that the decision they made will be overturned by politicians who just can't work out how to leave the EU, getting everything that the country wants from it. Mainly because their promises were lies.

Leave voters are feeling battered by a television media that had a strong commitment to remain. The Daily newspapers are adding to the conflict by telling their readers that they did the right thing and now everyone hates them
 for it. Nigel Farage is adding to it by being a rude, silly little man.  You can't blame the media; a good story is always about conflict and the media are there to entertain.

If you voted to leave the EU for any of the following reasons then you have my full support. I hope that someone in government (if there is still a government at the end of all this) has the ability to invoke article 50 and separate us from that political body for you.

1. The EU is too big. A political body with so many countries in it can never come to a complete agreement and someone will always feel put out.
2. The common currency project isn't working and has caused financial hardship for too many countries.
3. The solution to the Euro problem (5 Presidents report) of a United States of Europe, with banking union, a common budget and political union is a bonkers idea that you don't want the UK or any other country to sign up to.
4. The EU treated Greece really badly over their debt repayment crisis.
5. The EU has become too right ring and is perusing economic policies that would have made Norman Lamont think twice.
6. In the pursuit of a trade agreement with the US (TTip), instead of protecting workers rights they are actively deregulating.
7. The president of the European commission, Jean Claude Junker is a dick.
8. You would like the UKIP party members who were elected to a job they have no interest in doing to lose it and as the public insists on voting them in, leaving the EU seems a viable alternative.
9.  You are concerned that in allowing free movement of people within Europe, the continent has become a fortress which has stopped people from other continents who need to move into it for reasons of money, love or safety from doing so. 
10. You are an anarchist who would like there to be no government and just see how people get on. (Well, maybe not that one but 9 is such a silly number to end on)

However, if you voted to leave to "return to the Britain you knew," where you never saw a brown face or heard another language then you are a deluded racist (even if you think you're not) and I'm not going to let you into my bubble.

People I know who voted leave have been sharing this picture on social media.

I'm not sure if they are subtly trying to tell the world that they've changed their minds.

Monday, 13 June 2016

Confirmation Bias

Confirmation bias is the psychological phenomenon where people selectively collect evidence to confirm their previously held belief. We all do it and I can only assume it has some protective value for us humans. 

I've been noticing a lot of this phenomenon recently. 

It is amazing how every EU television debate has Twitter flooded with people saying how their side 'won the argument'

We like to be right. It feels very uncomfortable to be wrong.

Clever people, such as Boris Johnson (don't be fooled by the scruffy hair and word stumbling) can make use of this trait in people. "Ah, well, erm, that £350 million pound figure is wrong, yes I accept that but we give too much money to the EU and we give them £350 million pounds too much." You hear that and it confirms your belief that we give too much money to the EU and you reason that £350 million, which is a lot of money, could be the correct figure. Both sides are doing it. Cameron says we will all be doomed if we leave the EU and if you think we should stay in, you agree with him (even though, no one actually knows what might happen) and repeat his fears as though they were fact.

It's not just facts that are the issue. Personality politics is a huge factor. If you think that Cameron is a pig loving twit you are likely to hear his facts as false but if you are irritated by lizard-face Farage then you are more likely to believe  them.

There are big marmite personalities in this debate. 

Eddie Izzard's appearance on Question time caused many people a seriously uncomfortable moment of cognitive dissonance. He wasn't on their side but they liked him (or vice versa). Jeremy Corbyn on the Last Leg caused a similar outcry that wasn't worthy of either side's comments.  People who liked him before the programme said, "Did you see JC on the Last Leg? I thought he was rather good......funny in fact." People who disliked him were furious that he (a man who is notorious for having no sense of humour) could even be allowed on a comedy programme.

When people feel as though their side is losing the argument they cry that they were picked on, not listened to or interrupted. This frequently happens with Nigel Farrage, who isn't as skilled at factual argument as others are and Jeremy Corbyn, who isn't as skilled at the game of politics.

I have found this whole debate very difficult, as I'm struggling to weed out the personalities and clearly didn't have enough of a bias to confirm in the first place. I'm still of the opinion that we, the general public, are not qualified to judge and I am absolutely furious that they are spending £142.4 million pounds of tax payers money to  get us to answer a question that they can't decide on.

This morning, I am not only furious about the EU vote I am also devestated by the violence in America. 

Donald Trump has immediately stepped in to use it as confirmation of his own bias. He tweeted, "Appreciate the congrats on being right about radical Islamic terrorism." 

Then there is this weird thing that happens.  People put a spin on the story that reflects their own confirmation bias. The facts are that a man, originally from Afghanistan, told his dad that he was disgusted when he saw two gay men kissing, went out and bought a gun, walked into Orlando's "hottest gay nightclub", he may have shouted something about Allah and then he shot at hundreds of people, killing 50 of them.

The fact that this gunman was of Islamic faith is very convenient. It helps to maintain the status quo. The people in America who passionately believe in the right to bear arms don't have to let go of that belief because it was terrorism, not a gun that did it. 

Sky News had the saddest, most uncomfortable newspaper review I have ever seen.

Owen Jones was clearly very upset by the shooting and his own confirmation bias tells him that there is still a horrendous amount of violence directed at gay men (or the LGBT community). He felt the other two were focusing on their confirmation bias; guns and Islsmic terrorists who want to stop people enjoying themselves. He got up and left or walked off in a strop (depending upon your own bias) and the presenters continued without any compassion for his distress. 

History tells us that violence against minority groups (LGBT, Jews, women(ha, funny minority)) is common and that we prefer not to think about it. How long did it take after the war before people finally believed that the Hollocaust happened? Even when the pictures emerged people were still saying that they didn't believe it. 

Psychologists think that confirmation bias happens for two reasons. The first is motivational (sometimes called the Pollyanna phenomenon) where you can't bear to think the other thing might be true. They think that this creates the bias and then cognitive reasons, such as only being able to focus on one thought at a time, determine the size of the effect. 


I think it's a problem that us humans get stuck like this allowing every fact to confirm a belief, even when it actively disproves it.  I try to be as balanced as I can but know I am guilty of this phenomenon. I would try to stop doing it but fear that my brain might explode and when I am rushed to hospital the doctors would say that I'm fine because brains can't actually explode.

Friday, 3 June 2016

Wanna be in my gang?

When I was at school there was a cool crowd. There was at your school, as well, right? 

In my school it was the football gang: The boys who played football and the girls who followed them round, not doing very much except being mean to other girls. Girls who played football were definitely not allowed to join. They were 'lesbians' who weren't allowed to join anything. 

A peculiar thing happened at the very end of our time at school (before 6th form). The football boys decided that they would like to expand their potential shagging opportunities, so they made their group a bit more open. They advertised its attractiveness and went around singing, "wanna be in my gang, my gang, my gang?" to unsuspecting young girls, who had previously adopted the 'freeze and hope they don't notice me' stance within 100 yards of anyone from this group. Obviously Gary Glitter wasn't the social pariah he is today. They also cleaned up their act a bit. They got the girls in the group to be nicer and the girls in turn invited a few of the good looking, intelligent boys to join. 

I hasten to add I was in none of these groups but I am able to report on it from my position in the playground. The cool group occupied the area outside the fast food canteen, where people got slightly soggy chips from a hatch. There were steps up to the canteen and a concrete platform ran in front of the building. In front of the platform was a sheer drop into a flowerbed of roses. The cool kids were protected from falling into the thorns by a green painted iron railing, from which they used to swing, like monkeys in a zoo, perfecting their chin up and bench presses before having the girls admire their muscles. Across from this stage was a pillar holding up the humanities block, behind which was my place in the playground. 

The concrete platform got fuller and fuller until there was no room for a hanging raise, never mind a full somersault. The attractive intelligent boys turned out to be surprisingly good at press ups too. I wasn't that surprised, as these boys were in my classes and were the types who could do anything but the original football lads were floored; they just thought having a brain would weigh your head down too much and make exercise impossible.

The girls found it too taxing be nice to the new members of their fraternity for long and after a while went back to their old ways. Their favourite trick of a surprise skirt lift to laugh at the knickers underneath fell flat though as many of the new girls had very pretty underwear and were confident enough in their bodies not to mind giving a quick accidental flash. Worse, they were also classy enough, never to show their underwear on purpose. 

Soon,the group was looking unhappy. The founding members started to talk about leaving.
"It was our gang in the first place."
"Yeah, who do they think they are? Who invited them? I didn't, did you?"
"Nah, they just came and spoiled it."
"Can't we just get them to leave?"
They discussed who they would ask to leave. One of the main offenders was Suzie's boyfriend, Tim. Suzie was in the original gang, so Tim had to stay, which meant that Tim's mates would stay too. They threw their hands in the air, scratched thei heads and furrowed their brows.
"There's nothing for it. We'll have to go out on our own."

I can't tell you how successful their new adventure was because their new location wasn't one I could see from behind my pillar but now I wished that I'd followed them to find out.

These debates about the EU are reminding me of that time. I keep seeing people who say, "I voted to be part of the Common Market when I was twenty (1975) but now that all these other countries have joined (Poland, Romania) it's not what I thought it would be. Turkey even wants to join now and that would be the end of the world."
This is what France has been thinking since they finally let us in. The U.K. wasn't one of the founding members. We first applied to join in 1961 and were blocked by France who thought we weren't made of the right stuff and they kept blocking it until 1973. 


The breakaway gang may have gone onto bigger and better things or they may have been two sad lonely boys who used to be something special. The new gang carried on swinging like primates on the bars but they gave no indication of whether they wished the two defectors had stayed. 

If only I had changed my playground position in 1983 I might have an answer to the EU question.